Knee Walker vs Crutches: Which is the Better Mobility Aid?

alzheimerslab.com is reader-supported. I may earn a commission when you purchase via links on this page

If you’ve recently had an injury or surgery that affects your mobility, you may be wondering whether a knee walker or crutches are the better options for you. Both of these mobility aids have their pros and cons, and which one you choose will depend on your specific needs and preferences. Let’s take a closer look at knee walkers and crutches to help you make an informed decision.

Knee walkers, also known as knee scooters, are a type of mobility aid that allows you to move around while keeping weight off your injured foot or ankle. They look like a small scooters with a platform for your knee to rest on, and handlebars for steering and balance. Knee walkers are a great option if you have a lower leg injury or surgery that requires you to keep weight off your foot or ankle for an extended period.

Crutches, on the other hand, are a more traditional mobility aid that has been around for centuries. They consist of two long poles with padding at the top to rest under your armpits, and hand grips for support. Crutches are a good option if you have an injury or surgery that affects one or both legs and require support to move around.

So, which one is better for you? 

Let’s compare knee walker vs crutches based on some important factors.

Ease of Use

When it comes to ease of use, knee walkers have the upper hand. They require less upper body strength and coordination than crutches, as you simply rest your injured leg on the platform and use your other leg to push yourself forward. This means that knee walkers are often more comfortable and less tiring to use for long periods, making them a good option for people with chronic conditions or long-term injuries.

Crutches, on the other hand, can be more challenging to use, especially if you’re not used to them. You need to use your upper body strength to support your weight and move around, which can be exhausting and uncomfortable. However, once you get the hang of using crutches, they can be an effective mobility aid that allows you to move around with more freedom than a knee walker.

Mobility

When it comes to mobility, knee walkers and crutches both have their advantages and disadvantages. Knee walkers are great for indoor use, as they’re easy to maneuver and can easily navigate tight spaces. They’re also a good option for outdoor use on smooth surfaces like pavement or sidewalks.

However, knee walkers can be more challenging to use on uneven surfaces like gravel or grass, as the small wheels can get stuck or cause you to lose balance. They’re also less portable than crutches, as they’re bulkier and heavier to transport.

Crutches, on the other hand, are more versatile when it comes to mobility. They can be used both indoors and outdoors, and can easily navigate different surfaces with the right technique. They’re also much more portable than knee walkers, as they’re lightweight and can be easily carried or stowed away when not in use.

Comfort

Comfort is a key factor when it comes to choosing a mobility aid, as you want to be as comfortable as possible while recovering from an injury or surgery. Knee walkers are generally more comfortable than crutches, as they distribute your weight evenly and allow you to rest your injured leg while moving around.

Crutches, on the other hand, can be uncomfortable to use, especially if you’re using them for long periods. The pressure on your armpits and hands can cause pain and discomfort, and can even lead to nerve damage or skin irritation over time. However, there are specialized crutches available that are designed to be more comfortable, such as forearm crutches or axillary crutches.

Cost

Cost is another important factor to consider when choosing between knee walkers and crutches. Knee walkers tend to be more expensive than crutches, with prices ranging from a few hundred dollars to over a thousand dollars depending on the model and features. However, some insurance plans may cover the cost of a knee walker if it’s deemed medically necessary.

Crutches, on the other hand, are a more affordable option. Basic crutches can be purchased for as little as $20 to $30, with more advanced models costing up to a few hundred dollars. However, keep in mind that if you require specialized crutches for more comfort or support, the cost may increase.

Safety

Safety is a crucial factor to consider when using a mobility aid, as you want to prevent further injury or accidents while recovering. Knee walkers and crutches both have safety considerations to keep in mind.

Knee walkers are generally considered safe to use, as long as you follow the manufacturer’s instructions and use them on appropriate surfaces. However, they can be more unstable than crutches on uneven surfaces, and the small wheels can make them prone to tipping over. It’s important to be cautious and use the brakes when necessary to prevent accidents.

Crutches, on the other hand, require more balance and coordination to use, which can increase the risk of falls or accidents. It’s important to use them correctly and make sure they’re adjusted to the right height for your body. You should also wear appropriate footwear and avoid slippery or uneven surfaces.

Can knee walkers be used outside on uneven terrain?

From my experience, I can tell you that knee walkers can be used outside on uneven terrain, but with some caveats.

Knee walkers are generally designed to be used indoors or on smooth, level surfaces. However, some models are equipped with larger wheels and more rugged tires that can handle outdoor terrain. These models are specifically designed for outdoor use and can handle rough or uneven surfaces such as gravel, grass, and dirt.

That being said, it’s important to use caution when using a knee walker on uneven terrain. The smaller wheels on most knee walkers can make them more prone to tipping over or getting stuck, especially on steep inclines or declines. It’s essential to use the brakes to control your speed and avoid sudden movements that could cause the knee walker to lose balance.

Additionally, you should always wear appropriate footwear when using a knee walker outside. Shoes with good traction can help you maintain your balance and prevent slips or falls.

If you’re unsure whether a knee walker is suitable for your specific outdoor needs, it’s best to consult with your healthcare provider. They can provide guidance on the most appropriate mobility aid for your condition and help you determine if a knee walker is safe and effective for outdoor use.

Can knee walkers be used for any type of injury or condition? 

I can tell you that knee walkers can be used for many types of injuries or conditions that affect the lower leg or foot.

Knee walkers are most commonly used by individuals recovering from lower leg injuries, such as fractures, sprains, or surgeries. They provide a comfortable and convenient way to move around without putting weight on the affected leg or foot. Knee walkers can also be used by individuals with chronic conditions such as arthritis or neuropathy, which can make walking or standing for extended periods uncomfortable or painful.

However, knee walkers may not be appropriate for all injuries or conditions. Individuals with injuries or conditions that affect the knee, hip, or back may not be able to use a knee walker comfortably or safely. Additionally, individuals with balance or coordination issues may find it challenging to use a knee walker effectively.

If you’re unsure whether a knee walker is suitable for your specific injury or condition, it’s best to consult with your healthcare provider. They can evaluate your condition and recommend the most appropriate mobility aid for your needs. In some cases, crutches, a wheelchair, or other assistive devices may be more suitable. Your healthcare provider can guide how to use your chosen mobility aid safely and effectively to support your recovery and improve your quality of life.

Will insurance cover the cost of a knee walker or crutches? 

I can tell you that insurance coverage for knee walkers or crutches varies depending on your insurance plan and the medical necessity of the device.

In general, many insurance plans do cover the cost of knee walkers and crutches if they are deemed medically necessary by a healthcare provider. However, the amount of coverage can vary widely, with some plans covering the entire cost of the device and others covering only a portion.

If you’re considering purchasing a knee walker or crutches, it’s important to check with your insurance provider to determine your coverage. You can usually find this information in your plan documents or by calling your insurance company directly.

When speaking with your insurance provider, be sure to ask about any deductibles, co-pays, or other out-of-pocket expenses that may apply to the cost of the device. You may also need to provide documentation from your healthcare provider, such as a prescription or medical order, to prove medical necessity.

In some cases, insurance may not cover the full cost of a knee walker or crutches, or may not cover them at all. If this is the case, you may need to pay for the device out of pocket or consider other options, such as renting a knee walker or purchasing a used device.

It’s important to consider all of your options and weigh the cost and benefits of each before making a decision. Your healthcare provider can provide guidance on the most appropriate mobility aid for your needs, and a financial advisor or insurance specialist can guide navigating insurance coverage and managing out-of-pocket expenses.

Knee walker vs crutches. Which one wins?

Honestly, it is difficult to pick a winner as each device has its own unique advantages and disadvantages depending on the individual’s injury, condition, and personal preferences.

Knee walkers are often preferred by individuals who need to keep weight off of one foot or leg, as they allow for greater mobility and stability compared to crutches. They also tend to be more comfortable, with padded seats and adjustable handles that can accommodate a wide range of body types. However, knee walkers can be bulkier and less portable than crutches,

When it comes to choosing between knee walkers and crutches, there is no clear winner as each device has its own unique advantages and disadvantages. Knee walkers offer greater mobility and comfort, while crutches are more portable and versatile. 

Ultimately, the best choice depends on the individual’s injury or condition, personal preferences, and lifestyle needs. It’s important to consult with a healthcare provider and weigh all the options carefully to make an informed decision.